1. We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. Learn More.

Removal of the post count.

Discussion in 'The Site' started by Sulph, 7 September 2005.

  1. Sulph

    Sulph Goodbye...

    28 September 2003
    I am coming to you with an idea, you do not have to accept, however, i feel that this is an important issue.

    To get rid of spamming, I wont mention any names, i think that the post count should be removed, it has no purpose. People should be judged by the intelligence of their banter and not by the number of their post count, its ridiculous, once again, i am not mentioning any names but i think its blatantly obvious that some of us evo webbers have been posting over 200 posts within the last week, none of which serve any purpose.

    Ive seen this system be implemented at other forums and it has worked wonders, the members that are respected and looked up to are the ones that make the most sense, not make the most posts.
     
  2. Chris Davies

    Chris Davies At least, I think I am Staff

    14 May 2003
    Tranmere Rovers
    I agree with this actually (and no, this isn't a post boost!! I actually do agree as there's no real point to the posts count anyway, apart from the more sad people using it as a "my cock's bigger than yours" thing.
     
  3. Ike

    Ike permaninizated

    18 March 2003
    I agree, the Join Date is enough information.
     
  4. Slobber

    Slobber boycotting PES

    3 August 2003
    Merseyside, England
    Liverpool FC
    Yeah ditch it. I don't like post counts either.
     
  5. Milanista

    Milanista Mangiamoli! Staff

    19 December 2002
    London & Milan
    AC Milan
    Ditch or not, why would you judge respect by post?
     
  6. Tom

    Tom likes turtles Staff

    12 December 2001
    Hamburg
    Nooooooo, what about my lovely postcount then?!?!ß1ßß
     
  7. LemonJelly

    LemonJelly Bungie's Bitch Staff

    28 August 2002
    UK
    lol, nice one Kezz!

    I don't care about post count either, however will it really remove the spamming from some members?? I don't think it will help all that much, however if it means there is even a slight improvement then I am all for it.
     
  8. Chris Davies

    Chris Davies At least, I think I am Staff

    14 May 2003
    Tranmere Rovers
    As your last sentence said, even if there's a chance of an improvement it's worth it. I don't think it will remove too much spamming, but what's to lose? The post count serves no purpose anyway.

    Here's hoping it's implemented and that it helps - I mean there's a few really nice guys here who've done nothing wrong, but their post count is made up of well-dones and questions already answered, and it's incredibly annoying (just like real life though I suppose, when you've got your friend's sister's cousin's auntie's cousin's daughter on the blower telling you how Paul's left windscreen wiper is a slightly different thickness than the right one but the bloke at Kwik Fit wouldn't even look at it).

    (See, if there was no post count, here's an example of one post that may have been removed, and 60 seconds of your life you'd have back)

    Oh and Kezz, you could always put your post count in your sig and update it every time you make a post! :vik:
     
    Last edited: 7 September 2005
  9. FlawlessCowboy

    FlawlessCowboy Stunted

    5 July 2004
    Coventry, UK
    How about having a new rule where having your average number of posts per day, above a certain number, results in a ban?

    Would that work, or could people find a way around it?
     
  10. Dar

    Dar Fullonrapist Staff

    21 February 2003
    Dublin
    I dont like removing it altogether, as it can help highlight these people and they can be sent a PM or told to stop posting useless crap.

    I wonder is there any way it can be removed for normal users but left for mods to be able to see? That would be a perfect solution, and would stop the cock measuring contests (you'll never beat me anyway so dont try) and hopefully the people that feel the need to post a lot the few weeks after they join just to not be deemed a "n00b".

    *** This message was brought to you and typed by Dar's phallus ***
     
  11. Tom

    Tom likes turtles Staff

    12 December 2001
    Hamburg
    Actually, it sounds like a good idea to us as well, so we're gonna take a look into it. Unfortunately, there's no simple option for disabling it in our software panel, so Mart will have some digging to do :mrgreen:

    @Chris: Maybe I'm even gonna change the rules, so that it's only me who's allowed to have a .gif pic in sig as a counter ;)

    @Cowb0y: I think that's not possible, the flooding control seems pretty basic. And I don't think we have a daily spam problem anyway, do we?

    edit @Dar: Ask Mart as he's your boyfriend! 8)
     
  12. Dar

    Dar Fullonrapist Staff

    21 February 2003
    Dublin
    You think I posted without already consulting my honey?

    You're positively mad man,,,, MAD!!!
     
  13. Milanista

    Milanista Mangiamoli! Staff

    19 December 2002
    London & Milan
    AC Milan
    If you start getting banned for making a certain amount of posts, then whats the point of a forum? I for example make 10 or less posts a day, would that be spamming? What if I made 25 posts, but actual posts that say something instead of just "yeh".
     
  14. Mart

    Mart Executive Janitor Staff

    28 February 2002
    NYC
    Darlington FC
    Ok, post counts have disappeared from threads and profile pages except for mods/admins who can still see them. Easy enough to change back if necessary.

    Anywhere else they can be seen?
     
  15. :: JJ ::

    :: JJ :: Guest

    Post counts can still be seen in the Members List.
     
  16. Dar

    Dar Fullonrapist Staff

    21 February 2003
    Dublin
    Christ, why you replied I dont know?!

    :lol:
     
  17. proxi

    proxi Champions League

    9 February 2003
    Sheffield
    Tottenham Hotspur
    Post count gone??? Ah man i was near to 10,000.

    Honest people, i was!
     
  18. Slobber

    Slobber boycotting PES

    3 August 2003
    Merseyside, England
    Liverpool FC
    Yay. \o/
     
  19. hutch

    hutch Beaten by Chris Wright

    5 January 2003
    Oh you absolute bastards.
     
  20. Zygalski

    Zygalski Ninja Samurai

    2 February 2003
    London, UK
    England
    Just to let everyone know, I call people noobs no matter what their post count (or join date)

    ;)
     
  21. proxi

    proxi Champions League

    9 February 2003
    Sheffield
    Tottenham Hotspur
    Seriously, a wise move.

    Post counts are utterly pointless. People are not their post count, not matter what they believe
     
  22. gerd

    gerd Retired Footballer

    8 January 2002
    Over the moon
    KRC Genk, Spurs
    I'm absolutely gutted...this was the one and only reason i posted...naah serious...good decision.
     
  23. Mart

    Mart Executive Janitor Staff

    28 February 2002
    NYC
    Darlington FC
    Yoink!
     
  24. Sulph

    Sulph Goodbye...

    28 September 2003
    Thanks guys. No names were mentioned i see :p. Good on you.
     
  25. kingpug

    kingpug Guest

    Good idea really, although I post quite alot I wouldn't consider it as spam, but as you say having post counts visible is utter useless, but then again so is join date?
     
  26. Mart

    Mart Executive Janitor Staff

    28 February 2002
    NYC
    Darlington FC
    I quite like join dates, it's handy when someone's posted something like a free iPod thread, if they just joined up to post that then we can safely ban them straight away.
     
  27. kingpug

    kingpug Guest

    Yea, but then "some" people who joined like 3 years ago think they are better than those who just joined. I don't think people should be judged by join date or post count, but by their posts.
     
  28. Sulph

    Sulph Goodbye...

    28 September 2003
    Yes, but at least join dates dont affect spamming, only the post counts do.
     
  29. Clockender

    Clockender is back...but for how long?

    27 November 2001
    East Lower, Block 13
    Arsenal FC
    So the post count has been removed, is this a trial or a permanent thing?
     
  30. Mart

    Mart Executive Janitor Staff

    28 February 2002
    NYC
    Darlington FC
    Trial at the moment but it seems to be a popular choice.
     

Share This Page

Welcome to Evo-Web! As a guest you can browse some of our forums. If you want to join in the discussions and get full access please sign up here.