1. We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. Learn More.

Football League considers scrapping draws

Discussion in 'Football' started by :: JJ ::, 14 March 2007.

  1. :: JJ ::

    :: JJ :: Guest

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/6452013.stm

    What the hell are they smoking? :shock:
     
  2. Indigo Michigan

    Indigo Michigan Der Schwartz PES-Meister

    14 March 2007
    South Shields
    Newcastle United
    i'm sure they discussed something like this a while back... idiotic idea, tbf... it won't happen
     
  3. :: JJ ::

    :: JJ :: Guest

    I remember a few other leagues had a shootout in the event of a draw but now you just don't get them, and the idea of running from the halfway line to score is nothing new - the NASL had it as a tie-breaker in the 70's, which was much ridiculed elsewhere.

    Keep draws as they are
     
  4. Indigo Michigan

    Indigo Michigan Der Schwartz PES-Meister

    14 March 2007
    South Shields
    Newcastle United
    yea... and my suggestion, in terms of cups that flow through to extra time etc. is that instead of penalties it should go through to golden goal straight after 90minutes, swapping every 15 minutes until a goal is scored
     
  5. :: JJ ::

    :: JJ :: Guest

    Yeah but the problem with that idea is matches could go on til 3 in the morning because nobody's scored :lol:
     
  6. Indigo Michigan

    Indigo Michigan Der Schwartz PES-Meister

    14 March 2007
    South Shields
    Newcastle United
    it's possible... as is coming back from 3-0 down in the last 20 seconds... but you rarely see it... fatigue would play a massive part in matches after 90 minutes and they wouldn't last too long, besides, a penalty shoot-out could last just as long if you think about it
     
  7. Evo-liam

    Evo-liam Nufc

    1 June 2006
    Newcastle Upon Tyne
    Newcastle United
    pathetic idea tbh , its giving smaller clubs less chance of staying in leagues , they hold on for 90 mins against a big team and they loose on a shootout , The f.a need to get a life and stop messing around with our leagues , they already ballsed it up with the transfer window .
     
  8. Milanista

    Milanista Mangiamoli! Staff

    19 December 2002
    London & Milan
    AC Milan
    Forces teams to attack more if they know a draw is no longer an option.
     
  9. marukomu

    marukomu Ecchi otoko

    26 November 2005
    Okayama, Japan
    Man Utd, Stockport County
    forces the poorer teams to defend en masse and try to nick a win or hold onto a lead they may have through luck. It would kill the game in a lot of cases.

    If they want attacking football, they should reward goals. How about a bonus point for every 3 goals scored in a game? That way a game that ended 4-3 would a least give the losers that tried a point instead of a team trying to hold on and not coming out of their own half. A 3-3 draw would be 2 points each, etc

    Won't happen though.
     
    Last edited: 15 March 2007
  10. the_thing

    the_thing ps3!

    4 August 2004
    Toronto
    Juve, MU
    they could do it like the NHL. a point is gaurenteed for both teams if it goes to shootout but the winner of the shootout gets the extra points. just my opinion tho.
     
  11. :: JJ ::

    :: JJ :: Guest

    Football puritans would see this idea as yet another attempt to "Americanise" the game. I choose that term simply because of American sports and the fact that MLS used to use penalty shoot outs to decide matches that ended in a draw. The "bonus point" idea for tems scoring more goals was, if I recall, trialled one season in France, without success, so it never caught on anywhere.
     
  12. gerd

    gerd Retired Footballer

    8 January 2002
    Over the moon
    KRC Genk, Spurs
    I agree with the thing...
    JJ, MLS did not use penlaty shoot outs, but shoot outs...i.e. a players starts from the middle line with the ball and confronts the GK...
     
  13. :: JJ ::

    :: JJ :: Guest

    Ah like NASL did? Think I got my wires crossed with some other league.

    Whatever way the suggestion has been laughed off by chairmen and managers of FL clubs. Just as well really. :mrgreen:
     
  14. chelsea_fan

    chelsea_fan EPL LEAGUE

    3 December 2004
    northpole
    chelsea fc
    keep the f game the way it is!
     
  15. PetrovLFC

    PetrovLFC Raul!

    13 March 2005
    NW London
    Liverpool
    if it ain't broke, don't fix it.
     
  16. Rocky

    Rocky League 1

    11 May 2005
    I'm sure the Brazilians would love it.
     
  17. TikTikTikTikTik

    TikTikTikTikTik *****

    7 August 2004
    Liverpool
    Knobheads, why dont they spend time coming up with ways to fine/ban divers?! Surely they are bringing the game into disrepute and are a big reason why the game's popularity is decreasing. Instead they waste their time with this shit and fining managers for stating the bleeding obvious. I also dont agree with the goals = great game, fifa was never considered the best game when the results were 6-6 most of the time. A great game doesnt even need goals, aslong as the quality of play is good and the game is handled fairly. The quality part is a variable as there are different players/managers/finances/etc however the handling of the game fairly shouldnt be too hard.

    For a start ref's should award freekicks when a player tries to stay on his feet to keep possesion after a tackle. Most of the time ref's wave play on when a player tries this, and as is most likely lose the ball. Meaning there is no incentive for the player to stay on his feet to gain advantage, so they let themselves go down easily. And when the fa dont retroactively punish blatant divers (robben against tot the other day, although tbh every game i see him playing he falls over atleast once without any contact asking for a freekick) they have nothing too lose, at most a yellow card, and even when the ref has decided its a dive most of the time they dont even get booked.
     
  18. SPiTFiRE

    SPiTFiRE Eus├ębio forever

    6 April 2004
    SL Benfica
    Calcio Moderno?

    No fucking way please!
     
  19. curswine

    curswine Premiership

    3 May 2004
    Fleetwood
    I'm sure this was implemented in Paraguay (correct me if I am wrong) but I think they play a pen shoot-out until their was a winner and the winner of the penalty shoot-out got 2 points and the loser got 1.

    I think it is a good idea for amateur leagues but I am too much of a football puritan to advocate this idea for the professional game, pen shoot-outs are based too much on one skill to make it fair as anyone on their day can win a pen shoot-out maybe if the way of deciding the game was a bit more skilful then maybe but other wise it's a no for me.
     
  20. sattan_hussein

    sattan_hussein Championship

    6 December 2004
    Ryo de Janeiro
    Arsenal
    It was in some brazilian state championships too, but it added nothing to the game.
     

Share This Page

Welcome to Evo-Web! As a guest you can browse some of our forums. If you want to join in the discussions and get full access please sign up here.