I just played a cup final Man Utd v Everton. I was leading 1-0 from the 7th minute until the 79th minute when one of my defenders fouled their attacker in the box. problem was, I didn't even press a button, but my defender kicked out to tackle. they scored the pen. To cap it all, with 2 minutes to go, I passed the ball back to my goalie after being under pressure and he missed it completely and it rolled into the net. I lost 2-1.