Going Back To WE8:LE + WE9 Review

Discussion in 'Winning Eleven' started by Perky Intruder, 4 August 2005.

  1. I'm going back to Winning Eleven 8: Liveware Evolution I am afraid.

    Note: This review is based on my play as an analog user, the main issue I talk abot does not effect players who use the d-pad.

    After 3 matches, I have seen about forty to fifty sidesteps by my team which I never intended to do, most of them on first touches which distrupted my play. Everyone is moaning at filthydani, yes he is going about it in the wrong way and spamming, but I am afraid what he is saying has a lot of truth in it. The fact is I can not be bothered to learn how to use the d-pad to control my players, and I was actually still enjoying Winning Eleven 8: Liveware Evolution where I had the choice if I wanted to do fancy moves and sidesteps, I do NOT like it being forced upon me.

    So this is a direct warning to people thinking of purchasing the game, be prepared for a dramatic increase in the number of sidesteps.

    Personally I think it's a real shame, so much of the game I liked. The menu system and presentation really has improved ten fold, the kit customisation is very handy and the edit mode looks superb. There are so many great new animations but these are overshadowed by the number of uncessary sidesteps. Often I would be passing out of defence, my defender would control it, sidestep, get tackled, and consequently surrender possession, that really did enfuriate me. The shooting system is also brilliant, I hit some cracking efforts and although the R2 shot isn't the "curling shot" people had hoped for it certainly is different to the normal shot.

    Another aspect I didn't find endearing was the heading. The animations were definately improved, it was the results of the heading I found poor. A lot of times headers looked false and too fast, my first ever goal in WE9 came from a Joe Cole, yes, I did say Joe Cole, bullet header into the top corner, this was not something I was expecting.

    The other thing that struck me as odd was the gameplay, reading the general opinions I couldn't figure out what to expect, some people were saying it was slower, others saying it was faster. What I found was the general game player was slower, but the actual passing and dribbling was faster. Perhaps it takes some getting used to, but this came across as rather unrealistic, it was almost like the animations were too quick for the gameplay?

    The responsiveness of players is exceptional, you can really think before the ball gets to the players and play a quick first time pass, increasing the flexibility in attack build-ups, you can really play quick-fire passing triangles to split open your opposition. I did not notice any great changes in the off-the-ball AI, the runs were still slightly limited but the aerial through-balls and through-balls are now much more effective so you can make better use of the few runs your team do offer you :)

    One thing which I didn't like was the fact that when the ball is on the far side of the field (away from the camera) the camera does not zoom in like it does in previous versions. This makes it feel too far away when you are playing on the far flank and this led to countless mistakes, dribbling off the field etc.

    There are so many small inclusions which leave a smile on your face, as small as a player running into the net and putting their hands out to stop themselves tearing a hole in it. :) At the end of the day though, a sour taste is left in my mouth and this is what is making me head for the confines of Winning Eleven 8: Liveware Evolution.

    A real, real shame - I can only hope other people who use the analog stick can find a way to reduce this problem.

    Famitsu Style Rating: 31/40
    Last edited by a moderator: 4 August 2005
  2. ortegaman

    ortegaman League 2

    7 August 2003
    Well, the side step is not a problem.
    U played just 3 matches?
    i played 4...
    I found a way to chose if i want a sidestep or a 90° cut.
    If u r running and want the sidestep just tap D-pad like always but without R2 (i assume u know that)
    But... if u want to make a 90° cut u must do this... when u are running with the bal do a FAST DOUBLE TAP in the D-Pad then u dont gonna do a side step your player gonna do the 90° Cut.

    Come on man... be more optimist!
  3. ruffneckc

    ruffneckc Salad Yute!

    27 April 2003
    New York
    Arsenal FC
    Decent review trying to balance both the good and the bad but your disappointment sticks out like a sore thumb. I do feel that you should highlight that this review targets analog WE users. D-pad guys, like myself, I suspect will be less aggrieved by the side-step issue.
  4. I don't use the d-pad at all, I use the analog stick. :(

    Thank you, I will ammend the review to mention this.
  5. alvaroaze

    alvaroaze Non-League

    29 June 2005
    this "r2 always pressed" stuff sucks... and they chagend it because of the psp, i cant believe it! isnt there a way to disable this in the control menu? i cant believe they let you choose manual passing, how to cross and you cant change this!
  6. Doubla R

    Doubla R Argentina

    13 April 2005
    They should've make an option to switch back to R2+ right/left or leave it the way it was.. like the manual pass I think, you can aim and click or just aim.
    Last edited: 4 August 2005
  7. topkop

    topkop Non-League

    5 August 2003
    It's been only 3 matches, play more and you'll like it.
  8. kingpug

    kingpug Guest

    Yea, the more I play it the more I love it, I think people just need to give it time, I mean for me it feels totally different and will surely take a few weeks before I am ready to score.....or hit the target.
  9. kevano22

    kevano22 TDWFYU

    2 August 2003
    i dont know how anyone can play WE8LE after tocuhing WE9

    WE8LE - crap, poor,unresponsive, players cant controll the ball

    WE9 - address most of the problems ive ever had with the WE games

    I think we need to set the record here though, with the sidestep.

    On previous games, when you pressed R2 to sidestep, it was like an animation and it stood out. Its hard to say, but the sidestep didnt look smooth.

    Now in WE9 it all flows. Even if you do do the sidestep it doesnt feel like your in an animation, you have full control over it.

    Anybody who goes back to WE8LE, over WE9 in my opinion needs to have a serious, serious re-think
  10. TrebuTa

    TrebuTa League 2

    8 April 2004
    Going back to WE8LE is a step in the wrong direction. I play with the analog stick too. I can't do any tricks. So what? It still has many more things than WE8LE.
  11. I get the feeling people didn't even read my review. Please don't bother to comment unless you've read it. Trebuta, I have no idea what you are talking about. Kevano mate, if that's how you view the sidestep then you are lucky..I just think it looks unrealistic and ruins the gameplay. Let me ask you this, when do you see that move in real life? I'll give you a clue, it starts with n and ends with r.
  12. spaceman

    spaceman League 2

    18 June 2003

    Spot on.. when a new WE game arrives i usually can't make up my mind if i like it more than the previous version and it may take a few days to find that,then i feel yeah this is better than the last one, However since playing this version i can't quite belive how much i like it right from the off...

    As for WE8LE well you forgot to mention the terrible slowdown uless you dont use any of the angles from 1-9 and the too fast gameplay, i much prefer to play JL-WE8 than LE. I had even given it a try not using any of the angles just to see if i can get anything of the game but i just didn't like it..

    End of the day i say you can never please all, so it's take it or leave it..
  13. Zlatan#9

    Zlatan#9 Premiership

    26 December 2002
    WTF? They don't do sidestep with the d-pad? They do in my game, without holding R2. And yes, it's kind of annoying, I don't want to do a sidestep when I want to make a 90º cut. But I'll just have to manage coz the game is so good! :)
  14. cappz8

    cappz8 League 2

    20 March 2003
    Berlin City West
    first of all mr. perky intruder:
    i give YOU an advice on how often you see the side step in real life:
    it begins with: in every
    and ends with:
    single match in the world!

    i really can not understand the people whining about the automatic side step feature in the game.
    it is a god blessed feature for heavens sake.
    believe it or not, it looks ten thousand times better than the usual animations in past titles when a player tries to get the ball under control first touch wise.

    so get used to it like filthydani should as well and better love this game.

    its million miles better than we8le.

    like Kevano said, it adresses most of the issues i had with we8le!

    the shooting animations alone are worth playing we9 instead of we8le!

  15. Ike

    Ike permaninizated

    18 March 2003
    Not a bad review, but really, three games is way too early to properly rate the game in my opinion. I agree the sidestep is overdone, but it doesn't really ruin the flow the game for me, it just happens too often to look realistic. In a real match, the players will NOT do a sidestep on every second dribble they make. I switched from analog to d-pad a while ago so I'll probably get used to the double-tap thing when my dribbling in this version gets better.
    Last edited: 4 August 2005
  16. Rated Josh

    Rated Josh Guest

    I have read a post which said you have to tap quickly twice UP or Down to go 90° without doing side-steps...Is it true? even if you play with analog?
  17. Thanks Ike, I have played about 20 matches now, in single player vs. AI and against human opponent. I've noticed the issue is much less prominent in human matches, I think because the AI tends to use it so often it amplifies the unrealism factor. I really appreciate many aspects of the game, it's just whether I can get used to all this sidestepping business. After re-thinking my initial decision I would probably continue playing WE9 against human opponents, but I will continue my master league game on WE8:LE where it's not a sidestep-fest. :) :)

    I wasn't even going to dignify this comment with a reply, but I'll ask YOU this: show me ONE SINGLE video of a player doing the "sidestep move" in real life, if you do I'll retract everything I've said and send you 20 euros on paypal.
    Last edited by a moderator: 4 August 2005
  18. Slobber

    Slobber boycotting PES

    3 August 2003
    Merseyside, England
    Liverpool FC
    Can someone explain to me how this whole side step thing is done in the game please? I still don't quite understand it. Is it now impossible to make 90 degree turns without side stepping?
  19. Sulph

    Sulph Goodbye...

    28 September 2003
    I cant get the 90 Degree turn working, even though i hvnt seen it happen in real life much
  20. More or less, I think it's worse for analog users though.

    A lot of people used to dribble using sidesteps anyway so it's no different for them, but the people who don't dribble with skills and sidesteps but just cutting in and out it totally effects the gameplay for them, I think thats what people aren't understanding here.
  21. filthydani

    filthydani Guest

    I am actually thinking to do the same...
    That's why i am really pissed from the game...

    As i told you guys, I won't be the only one who will be moaning about this, (sorry for the word moaning Perky, what you are saying is all true)

    I have been playing this game since winning eleven 3, never had any major problems with the gameplay when they release new updated version every year, there might be some little stuff that annoyed me like lots of fouls in (we6) and hand balls in (we7), but those stuff didn't effect the game play too much, so I could deal with em with no problems…

    What happened in winning eleven 9, is something i never expected to happen at all. i don't mind changing the dribbling system, but changing it to the worse is something unacceptable, didn’t expect konami would do such big mistakes…

    I hope they re-release winning eleven 9 again with the old dribbling system....
    unless i am not going to bother with this game anymore...
  22. Sulph

    Sulph Goodbye...

    28 September 2003
    But then it makes it more realistic doesent it.
  23. filthydani

    filthydani Guest

    No one dribbles with the side steps, I rarely had to use it when playing pes4 online,
    I actually use it only when I want to show off or something, it was completely useless and stupid…
  24. mcruz

    mcruz League 2

    31 January 2005
    rio de janeiro, Brasil
    Vasco and Real Madrid
    One thing which I didn't like was the fact that when the ball is on the far side of the field (away from the camera) the camera does not zoom in like it does in previous versions. This makes it feel too far away when you are playing on the far flank and this led to countless mistakes, dribbling off the field etc.

    totally agree with you!!!!!!!!!!! it´s a crap thing all this distance.
  25. Zygalski

    Zygalski Ninja Samurai

    2 February 2003
    London, UK
    If you think about it, when you are dribbling with a real football, can you actually turn 90 degrees and keep moving? Wouldn't that be a bit of a robotic motion?

    Can't you turn to the side by going through the diagonal first?

    Also, it's great how dani continues to tell us how stuff is, even though it's just his opinion and is not true for many people. Get a grip kid ;)
  26. filthydani

    filthydani Guest

    Would you say that before playing we9? No.
    would you say this if they actually havent changed it in this version?

    You just say this becouse you think whatever konmai dose is right...

    Get a grip
  27. Lovejoy!

    Lovejoy! Veteran

    2 August 2005
    you're obviously not skillful enough mate..
  28. True Zygalski, but then you wouldn't do that kind of computerised dragging of the ball to the side and then continuing forward. The only person I see do that is Joe Cole who does it as a special dribbling trick. I've never seen it to the extent it is present in WE9. In real life players either knock it sideways and then knock it forwards, the technique of the player depends how quickly and precisely they can do this.
  29. johan

    johan Guest

    Got my copy earlier and to be honest WE8LWE is a pile of crap compared to WE9. Playing WE9 or watching real football its not any different. And all this autho-dribling and auto stepovers..I for some reason don`t get them at all..maybe because I like to pass the ball around and stuff... whoever thinks WE8LWE is better then WE9 is obviously blind.
  30. cappz8

    cappz8 League 2

    20 March 2003
    Berlin City West
    lets end the discussion with this wonderful statement.

Share This Page

Welcome to Evo-Web! As a guest you can browse some of our forums. If you want to join in the discussions and get full access please sign up here.